The Stealth IRA: Health Savings Account (HSA)


The Health Savings Account is the best tax-advantaged account available. If you are on a high-deductible health insurance plan, make sure you have an HSA.

When you’re signing up for a high-deductible insurance plan, you may see an unfamiliar option to open a Health Savings Account. One of the newest savings accounts created by Congress, you’d be excused for not understanding how a Health Savings Account can fit into your overall financial strategy. Read on for the basics of a Health Savings Account and how you can turn it into a Stealth IRA if you want to supercharge your retirement savings.

Qualifying for a Health Savings Account

If you’ve enrolled in a high-deductible health plan, you qualify for an HSA. The HSA is meant to compliment the high-deductible insurance plan. By accepting the higher deductible, the government wants you to put aside money in a tax-free account to cover health expenses. There are no income restrictions on contributing to an HSA, which makes it ideal for lawyers.

How a Health Savings Account Works

If you have a high-deductible health plan at work, HSAs are a no-brainer. Unlike a Flexible Savings Account where you must use the funds each year or risk forfeiture, you own the money deposited into an HSA and do not need to spend it each calendar year. If you end your HSA-eligible insurance coverage (e.g. because you switch to a non-HDHP plan), you lose the ability to contribute additional money to your HSA but you keep the funds already in the HSA.

The funds in your Health Savings Account can be used for a qualified medical expense. Qualified medical expenses are those expenses that would generally qualify for the medical and dental expenses deduction on Schedule A of Form 1040. These expenses are described in detail in Publication 502, Medical and Dental Expenses, but generally include expenses not reimbursed by your medical insurance provider, such as co-pays, laboratory fees, prescription drugs, vision care and deductibles.

Over-the-counter drugs are not included. In general, I’m not too concerned about what does and does not qualify as medical expenses, as I expect to either use my HSA later in life when I experience real medical problems or will withdraw it after the age of 65 when I can do so without penalty (more on that below).

The Triple Tax-Advantages of a Health Savings Account

A triple tax-advantaged account is the holy grail in savings. Your money is not taxed going into, while growing, or, if used for medical expenses, when coming out of an HSA.

Let’s break it down:

  1. The money contributed to an HSA is not subject to federal income tax at the time of deposit;
  2. The returns from investments inside the HSA are not subject to federal income tax as your account grows; and
  3. Withdrawals are not subject to federal income tax if used for qualified medical expenses. Further, HSA funds roll over and accumulate year to year if not spent, so there’s no chance of losing your funds at the end of the year as is the case with Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs).

If you don’t use your HSA for qualified medical expenses, it can be withdrawn without penalty at any time after you reach 65. At age 65, it’s treated like a Traditional IRA, so you’ll only pay income taxes (and this is the key benefit of the Health Savings Account).

Using your Health Savings Account as a Stealth IRA

We’ve already established that you can use your Health Savings Account to pay for qualified medical expenses. But if you end up never having any qualified medical expenses, you can withdraw from the Health Savings Account after age 65 as if it were a Traditional IRA.

I’m treating my HSA as a retirement account, therefore I have no plans to withdraw the funds. I max out the account every year and am investing the money in the stock market using index funds. My hope is that it will compound and grow without being touched until I’m 65.

If I have an expensive medical problem between then and now, I will use the HSA funds to pay for the medical expenses. In many ways, this gives me comfort that I have money saved up should the health care system fail me.

If I reach 65 without touching the HSA funds, I will use them as part of my asset strategy at that time. That likely means I will either: (1) continue to hold the funds and use them for qualified medical expenses, thus never paying taxes on the money; (2) withdraw the funds and pay low income taxes or (3) withdraw the funds using receipts for medical expenses incurred over the previous 30 years (as discussed below).

Other Factors to Consider for Health Savings Accounts

What Types of Investments Can I Make with HSA Funds?

An HSA can be invested in the same way as a 401(k) or an IRA, depending on the options offered by your HSA provider.

One popular HSA provider offers a range of low-cost index funds, including funds that I invest in like the Vanguard S&P 500 and Vanguard Total International Stock Fund. With expense ratios of 0.17% and 0.19% respectively, those numbers are hard to beat.

One downside is that your HSA provider may charge you an account maintenance fee. My HSA provider charges $3.50 a month regardless of the balance. At $42 a year, it’s a hefty amount for a small $1,000 balance, but since the fee is fixed it becomes less of an issue as your account balance grows. My provider requires me to maintain $1,000 in cash, which is a little frustrating since it limits the amount you can invest in the market.

Can I Switch HSA Providers?

Many people don’t realize that you’re not required to use the HSA provider selected by your employer, unlike 401(k)s. You can use any provider you like.

Don’t like the investment options available to you? Unhappy with the amount of fees? There is a growing market of investment firms offering better HSA options. This is something I’d like to look into myself.

If you choose to use a separate HSA provider, make sure your employer sends the check directly to the HSA provider so that you can save on payroll taxes. Like pre-tax insurance premiums, HSA contributions are not subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes as long as the plan is classified as a Section 125 plan.

Withdrawal Strategies for HSA Accounts

HSA participants do not have to obtain advance approval from their HSA trustee or medical insurance company to withdraw funds. Depending on your HSA trustee, you can withdraw funds using a debit card, writing a check against the account or by following a reimbursement process.

Funds can be withdrawn for any reason, but withdrawals that are not for qualified medical expenses are subject to income taxes and a 20% penalty. Account holders are required to retain documentation of the qualified medical expenses. In an audit it will be your burden to prove to the IRS that your withdrawals were for qualified medical expenses.

Health Savings Account Contribution Limits

The Stealth IRA: Limits to Health Savings Account Contributions

State Tax Treatment

State tax treatment of HSAs varies. As of 2019, two states (California and New Jersey) do not recognize HSAs and do not allow deductions of HSA contributions for state income tax purposes. In NYC, contributions to an HSA will be free of federal, state and local income taxes (triple win!).

HSA Accounts at Death

When an HSA account holder dies, the funds in their HSA are transferred to the beneficiary named on the account. If the beneficiary is a spouse, the transfer is tax-free. If the beneficiary is not a spouse, the account is no longer an HSA and it becomes taxable to the beneficiary in the year the HSA owner dies (But the amount taxable to the beneficiary is reduced by any qualified medical expenses for the decedent that are paid by the beneficiary within 1 year after the date of death). See IRS Publication 969.

This is a generally favorable treatment of the HSA funds, in that you can transfer them to your spouse tax-free. However, given that the account is taxable to a non-spouse beneficiary, it seems to make sense to expect to use up the HSA during your lifetime.

Three Ways to Manage Your HSA

Having covered the basics, there are really three different ways to treat your health savings account:

Use the Health Savings Account as a Stealth IRA

As described above, I’m choosing to use my Health Savings Account as a Stealth IRA for now. That means I’m maxing out contributions every year and not withdrawing funds to pay for qualified medical expenses. I’m hoping the money will compound inside the account and continue to grow tax-free such that I’ll be able to use it for medical expenses later in life or, if I remain healthy, as a Traditional IRA once I reach age 65.

Pay for Current Out-of-Pocket Medical Expenses

If I haven’t convinced you that the HSA is a Stealth IRA and should be used in retirement, you can always use the HSA to pay for current out-of-pocket medical expenses.

Thanks to the fairly generous definition of qualified medical expenses, there are plenty of opportunities to use the funds to pay for current expenses. Since the process of reimbursement is simple, I certainly take no issue with someone wanting to reimburse themselves in real time from their HSA as expenses are incurred.

The goal is reduce the drag of taxes on your retirement and savings, so I’m all far any smart strategy for using the system as it has been designed. It only takes a little bit of tax planning to reap significant rewards. Using HSA funds to pay for current medical expenses is a great approach.

Save Receipts for Future Reimbursement

When Congress set up the HSA they made it clear that at your own election you can reimburse yourself for qualified medical expenses. They didn’t say when you have to make the reimbursement.

In other words, you can incur the qualified medical expense today but apply for reimbursement later – much later. Perhaps even 45 years later. The benefit of course is that your money is compounding tax free during the interim and you can then withdraw it in retirement without having to pay expenses.

Sound too cute and clever to be true? It’s not. See Question 39 to IRS Bulletin 2004-33 Notice 2004-50:

An account beneficiary may defer to later taxable years distributions from HSAs to pay or reimburse qualified medical expenses incurred in the current year as long as the expenses were incurred after the HSA was established. Similarly, a distribution from an HSA in the current year can be used to pay or reimburse expenses incurred in any prior year as long as the expenses were incurred after the HSA was established. Thus, there is no time limit on when the distribution must occur. However, to be excludable from the account beneficiary’s gross income, he or she must keep records sufficient to later show that the distributions were exclusively to pay or reimburse qualified medical expenses, that the qualified medical expenses have not been previously paid or reimbursed from another source and that the medical expenses have not been taken as an itemized deduction in any prior taxable year

Keeping track of my receipts for 35 years seems overly complicated to me and doesn’t fit within my investment policy statement of keeping investments simple.

However, I may keep track of medical receipts anyway as part of my own system of using automated computer slaves to organize my information. While I’m not going out of my way to capture qualified medical expenses, the information is certainly being retained and I expect to have the ability to search the information in the future – or maybe Siri will do it for me.

If I have access to these receipts, I would have no problem spending a few hours rounding them up and making a large withdrawal based on those receipts. This will even be easier since I plan on making no previous withdrawals, thus eliminating any risk that I might double count a qualified medical expense.

If one day I’m faced with the problem of whether I have access to medical receipts to justify taking the money out tax free or whether I need to pay income taxes on the amounts withdrawn – Well, we should all be so lucky.

Is it Worth Switching to an HDHP to Have Access to an HSA?

Only you can answer this question by examining your own medical expenses. For many young lawyers with little or no medical expenses, switching to an HDHP and investing in an HSA is going to make a lot of sense.

To make the calculation, add up the premium savings by switching to an HDHP. Subtract the additional costs incurred by paying a higher deductible based on your expected annual medical expenses. If the number is negative, that’s the cost of having access to an HSA. If the number if positive, you should feel pretty comfortable about making the switch.

Let’s talk about it. Do you have an HDHP? Why or why not? Are you saving in your HSA and treating it like a Stealth IRA? Let us know that strategy you’re taking in the comments below.

Joshua Holt

Joshua Holt A practicing private equity M&A lawyer and the creator of Biglaw Investor, Josh couldn’t find a place where lawyers were talking about money, so he created it himself. He spends 10 minutes a month on Personal Capital keeping track of his money and his latest deal involved purchasing office space on the EquityMultiple real estate crowdfunding platform.

Save more money than your friends

The Biglaw Investor email list covers personal finance, financial independence, investing and other stuff for lawyers that makes you better. Join us and get ahead of your co-workers.

    Fifteen thoughts on The Stealth IRA: Health Savings Account (HSA)


    1. Darn. I’m going to be in Alabama so no saving on those state income taxes. However, I had no idea HSA’s existed and will be contributing to it. Triple threat savings? Sign me up! 40 years of saving to do…

        1. Hi Josh,
          You have really done your homework and this is another excellent piece, well laid out and easy to understand. Your lawyer readers are learning so much they don’t even know exists until you point it out. So far, it all seems centered on making money or saving it. What a gold
          mine! I hope that your goal is for each email to ultimately be a chapter in what can only become a best seller! Blogging a nonfiction book is the way to go.
          The only thing I’d suggest is more THOROUGH PROOF READING. Typos are one thing, but
          no one realized you had forgotten to include YOUR NAME! Major oversight.
          Anyway, great job. Keep up the good work. I’m very glad we’ve met, Josh.
          To your success!
          Diane

          1. Haha Diane, thanks for the comment. You are correct, more thorough proof reading is always a good thing. I’ll speak to my editor about it immediately. I certainly aim to publish every post free of spelling and grammatical errors. If you see anything, feel free to call me out. I’ll fix it!

            And thanks for keeping me honest.

            -Josh

            p.s. Great idea about writing a book slowly but surely. 🙂

    2. Great article – I wish there was more stuff out there on the contribution limits. I’m in a tricky scenario and can’t find anything about it online (spouse and I were in different jobs – he had an HSA, I didn’t, then I started a new job and elected HSA, then he lost his coverage and joined my plan, now I’m covering him as a domestic partner until we get married in December.
      Don’t think we can do the full $6750 since we both didn’t have an HSA for the full year. Do you know?

    3. My employer contributes to my HSA a set amount, and then I’m putting in the rest to max it out. Interestingly they contribute per paycheck as I do, so it’s not like they put it all in at the beginning of the year, which would be neat, but oh well.
      I am also planning to not touch it for now. That means medical expenses go on my rewards card and get me closer to my trip next year.

    4. I really like your post about stealth IRAs. I forgot about the saving receipts and taking a large withdrawal at a later date.

      I haven’t read anything to suggest that HSA is are subject to change from the tax cut and jobs act of 2017. Have you heard differently?

    5. I love how this is written assuming no large medical expenses. Have kids 🙂 You’ll eat though most, if not all of your HSA contributions every year. I know I have for the last two years.

      I’m glad I can pay our medical expenses with pre-tax dollars, but I no longer consider my HSA account as a stealth IRA.

    6. I think you make good points, but I don’t think this actually works out to your advantage when you have spouse and kids. Health insurance is too important and the likelihood of needing it is actually quite high. I wouldn’t want to incur the out-of-pocket maximums.

      1. Are you saying that a high-deductible health insurance plan isn’t worth it vs a traditional PPO plan? Or are you saying that if you have an HDHP you wouldn’t open up a health savings account? Because if you have an HDHP, the health savings account is a must. If you’re deciding between a PPO vs an HDHP, I agree that the health savings account in and of itself doesn’t make the HDHP better for you.

        1. Your first sentence. If you have another option, I’d go with that. If high deductible plan all you have, after HSA is no brainer. Maybe I missed that nuance in article.

    7. I think something to consider, for your commenters that are complaining that kids are too pricey for a HDHP, is that not *all* kids are pricey, healthwise.

      I think many HDHP plans cover preventative care 100%, so the annual physical for the kids and shots and so forth should be covered with no problem. However, once the kids are born, most healthy kids would probably be ok on a HDHP, save for the occasional urgent care visit for a flu or something.

      But definitely, to each their own. If your family has a recurring habit of going to the doctor, then maybe keep yourself in the PPO. But overall, now that my kids are born (birth is expensive!) I’m going to look at chatting with the wife about getting a HDHP and an HSA set up.

    8. WHETHER THE HSA IS “WORTH IT” FOR A FAMILY WITH CHILDREN

      I have four kids, and I have had an HSA for years. Since I am self employed as an attorney, using an HSA account is a futile attempt to try and control, to some extent, the cost of my monthly health insurance premiums. Prior to the “Affordable” Care Act, I paid $450 a month to insure my family with excellent insurance. For 2019, the only Gold Plan available, which is not as good as my pre-ACA insurance, costs $3,967 a month (i.e., $48,000 annually).

      My Bronze HSA-eligible plan will be only $1867 a month (i.e., $22,404 annually).

      In prior years, I have experienced both low and high medical expenses. One year, my wife was pregnant, broke her foot (long story) and gave birth. One of my children broke a bone playing high school sports. I used the amount in the HSA to pay medical bills, and my family’s medical expenses for the year exceeded the annual contribution limit to the HSA. It was my first year using an HSA, and I was a little disappointed to end the year with a $0 balance in the HSA and the need to pay further medical expenses out of pocket.

      Last year, with four kids, I spent less than $500 on medical and dental expenses for the whole family, and I did not use the HSA account to pay those bills.

      It is not always easy to predict whether the HSA will be “worth it” ahead of time.

      A CAUTION TO THOSE PURCHASING HEALTH INSURANCE ON THE EXCHANGE

      The self employed attorney purchasing health insurance on the exchange must exercise caution if claiming a premium tax credit subsidy. Being self employed, income is unpredictable. If household income exceeds 400% of the poverty level for a family of your size, then the entire amount of the subsidy must be repaid with your taxes. Quite literally, earning $1 more of income can cost a household $20,000 in taxes. There is nothing else like this in the tax code of which I am aware. The thinking in the Democratic Congress at the time was that when a family reaches that income level, it can “afford” the health insurance. For 2018, 400% of the federal poverty level for a family of four is approximately $98,000.

      Earning $97,999 means you are entitled to approximately $20,000 as a credit against your monthly premiums, making the insurance more “affordable.”

      If you earn one dollar more, however, that credit disappears, and the government will demand it all back. It’s known as the ACA “cliff.”

      Health insurance runs anywhere from 24% to 49% of household annual income at the 400% poverty level.

      The notion that health insurance is affordable at income levels of 400% of the federal poverty level is a joke. For those earning 800% of the federal poverty level, that might be true, but health insurance is no longer “affordable” for those households at or barely above the 400% of poverty level, because the available plans eat up such a large percentage of household income.

      I thought this important to mention because so many self employed attorneys with families have unpredictable income that ends up right around the 400% of poverty level, perhaps ending up above or below that level, with serious consequences at tax time. Careful planning and use of 401(k) accounts, traditional IRA accounts, and HSA accounts, can bring the household income down below the 400% level and save the family a $20,000 tax hit.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *