In the previous post of this two-part series, I argued that budgets are for beginners. Why box yourself into projected spending when you can review an automatically generated spending report and adjust accordingly? Today we’ll argue the other side.
To understand why budgeting is for pros, let’s first think about professional athletes. I can think of no better example than fan favorite Roger Federer, who recently secured his 18th Grand Slam title at the Australian Open in January. Federer is the all time leader in Grand Slam titles (his nearest competitors are Pete Sampras and Rafael Nadal, both tied at 14) and is making the case for being considered the greatest male tennis player of all time.
Federer’s win at the Australian Open is even more impressive because he’s 35 – long past the “prime” of his career – and the fact that he hadn’t played in a grand slam event since Wimbledon in the summer of 2016 due to a knee energy.
So, how did he get back on top?
As I recently had reaffirmed in Grit (thanks for the recommendation Anita), remarkable accomplishments like winning the Australian Open are a combination of thousands of unremarkable steps that happen behind the scenes. Humans, however, are quick to invoke “talent” when describing these remarkable feats. Why? Because it’s a defense mechanism employed by our egos that lets us know that we don’t need to compete with Roger Federer. Had we seen how Federer practices each and every day – and how ordinary that all seems – we might start to put pressure on ourselves to do the same. And, if we don’t live up to that expectation, then maybe we’re not as good as Roger Federer.
So we fall back on describing Roger Federer as having innate “talent” that we could never possess. It’s easier.
Professional athletes aren’t immune from this thinking as well. If you’ve ever taken an interest in elite athletes, you know that they’re all doing everything humanly possible to compete at the highest level possible. The perfect diet? Check. Insane workout schedule? Done. For an elite athlete, they’d be willing to do almost anything to achieve an extra 1% edge. That 1% edge could blow the competition out of the water.
We see this with the rampant use of performance enhancing drugs. When you’re that competitive, any edge is the difference between winning and losing. There’s a great documentary on this called Bigger, Stronger, Faster but the premise is pretty simple. When you’re elite, you’re not looking at making 10% or 20% gains. You need the slightest edge to overcome your competitors because the slightest edge is all that’s left.
So, if you’re a personal finance ninja, what can you do to get a 1% edge? Why, you could budget of course.
Budgeting lets you dial in your expenses exactly. You Need a Budget (YNAB) has a pretty easy explanation of how budgeting works.
- Give Every Dollar a Job. All incoming money needs to have a specific purpose. You’re in charge, so you chose and prioritize appropriately.
- Embrace Your True Expenses. It’s those large, less-frequent expenses that are messing up your budget. Instead of dealing with them as they come up, take the lumpy expense and divide by 12. Now you know the true cost of your expenses each month.
- Roll With The Punches. Boxers move in the same direction as the punch to lessen the blow. When (not if) you overspend in budgeting, just keep going. Be flexible.
- Age Your Money. The money you spend today should be the money you earned last month. There’s no stress if you’re spending the previous month’s earnings because you’re not worried if you have enough money in the bank to cover a credit card bill.
It’s easy to see why this approach could lead to less stress (if you stay on top of it) and zero margin for mistakes.
For one, you’re being intentional about each incoming dollar which means you won’t be allocating it to that Hulu subscription you never use. Second, you’re paying attention to your true expenses. Fixed monthly expenses are the easiest when it comes to budgeting. In fact, it’s so easy that you could do all the budgeting in your head.
But your budget isn’t entirely made up of fixed expenses.
First, there’s the variable expenses (e.g. electricity). But those aren’t that hard either, because they don’t move up or down by very much.
But what about Christmas gifts? Do you know your annual travel expenses? These are much harder things to include in a budget. Most people just deal with the expenses as they come up, but with YNAB you’re forced to think about them and account for them on a monthly basis.
After that, it’s all about being flexible. When you overspend in one category, you need to shift money from another category or you have to carry the negative balance into the next month. That’s pretty much how money works. You can’t spend money you don’t have without going into debt. It’s a simple concept, but something that is easy to miss. If you’re making a lot of money, you won’t even realize that you’re borrowing from yourself until one month when you overcorrect and cut all spending to get back on track. We’ve all had those situations.
Before I started budgeting with YNAB, things like a tax refund or a month with three paychecks were my opportunities to reset.
Does that sound like something you’ve done?
If so, you might be doing a great job saving a lot money, but could you be doing 1% better. What would happen if you banked the entire third paycheck or tax refund rather than using it to pay off a credit card bill that got a little higher than you expected? For some, this might be a big deal. For others, it won’t matter. Each person needs to find the right balance.
Whatever you decide is best for you, I’d hate for anyone to think budgeting is hard.
My YNAB system is pretty simple. It works like this. Each month I get paid. Each month I record an entry showing that my paycheck arrived and I categorize it as money that’s available next month.
On the first of each month, I “budget” for the month by clicking one button that auto-populates that month with the budget amounts from the last month. I tweak as necessary. Included in those monthly expenses are things that I pay for yearly (like Christmas gifts or my Dropbox subscription). I suppose you could say that I’m “saving” money for these yearly expenses but I just look at it like I’m spending $100 a month rather than saying I spend $1200 each year on Christmas gifts.
Then, I record expenses in the system as they occur. This is much like balancing a checkbook or using Quicken. It takes me about 15 minutes a week and it’s only slightly harder than reviewing my actual credit card statement to make sure there aren’t any incorrect charge. As I enter each transaction, YNAB takes the category information for the entry and applies the expense to the budget. At a glance, I can quickly see how much I have left in each category (much like a digital version of the envelope system).
Inevitably, I screw things up during the month. I spend more than I anticipated. I have an annual bill that I forgot to put into the system. To handle it, I simply re-allocate money from another category (or bring in new money from savings) and keep going. If it’s an annual expense, I create a new budget category and start allocating $10 a month (or whatever it is) each month towards the expense.
Using YNAB has been a game changer when it comes to (1) thinking about money and (2) dialing back expenses. First, I never feel guilty about spending money. If it’s in the system, I’ve already accounted for it and if it’s not, I just move some money over. That means when a quarterly expense comes up, I don’t think “Oh shit, it’s time for that expense … guess I should spend less on restaurants this month.” Instead, I just pay the expense and move on. Second, no money goes out of the door unnoticed. This is a pretty powerful motivator to make changes when I’m spending money on something that isn’t maximizing happiness. Third – and I can’t emphasize this enough – with YNAB, managing my finances really is a “mind like water” experience.
I was always saving a lot of money before. But now, I’m saving even more and I hardly think about it.
Yet, I know that many readers don’t want to budget. In the previous article, Budgeting is For Beginners, I went over all the reasons why you don’t need a budget, so I won’t rehash them here. If you’re not budgeting, you’ll probably be just fine. Pay yourself first and it’ll all work out okay. But if you want mind like water or to be a pro that wants the 1% edge, give budgeting a chance.
Joshua Holt is a practicing private equity M&A lawyer and the creator of Biglaw Investor. Josh couldn’t find a place where lawyers were talking about money, so he created it himself. He spends 10 minutes a month on Personal Capital keeping track of his money and is always negotiating better student loan refinancing bonuses for readers of the site.
Twelve thoughts on Budgeting is For Professionals
A comment from a reader sent via Lawyer Slack (apologies if people are having trouble commenting today):
“One thing that has helped in our budgeting is weekly meetings. Each Wednesday we (my fiance and I) for about 15 minutes to discuss where we’re at on our monthly budget plan. Did we spend too much at dinner the other night? Did something unexpected pop up? Are we on track for our debt payoff goal? These short meetings help us stay on track with the budget. When we first started budgeting we only talked about the budget once a month. Next thing we knew we’d get to the 20th or so and be in serious danger of blowing our budget out of the water.
Beyond budgeting, these meetings and budgeting in general have improved communication between us. We’ve been together for about 5 years and never before have we communicated with one another like we do now. We’re able to recognize issues before they become problems. We’re able to work together towards our financial goals.
It’s not that we had a poor relationship or communication before. Budgeting just gave us that 1% edge.”
I was more on board with the “Budgets are Not Sexy” philosophy that stated Budgets are for Beginners.
When you’re well off and making Biglaw or Doctor Money, there shouldn’t be competition for the highest savings rate or the fastest to FI. As long as you’re making reasonable decisions, each of us has the opportunity to be financially successful.
We can all be winners.
Thanks PoF. Great to see we disagree on something. I was beginning to wonder …
I hope the point is clear that it’s about efficiency and making sure each dollar is working to maximize an individual’s happiness and not about racing/competing with someone else.
My in-laws are both in tech. They have a chance to make a lot of money very quickly with their companies and live a great life. As a doctor I agree with PoF., as long as we are making reasonable decisions, high earners should be able to retire comfortably.
As I say, with my in-laws they are more likely to retire at 45 then me, but I am more likely to retire by 55 then they are. If they hit it big, then they are done at a young age. If not, they will work longer than I will. Either way, I will be out by 55.
I also agree that budgets are not sexy. They stress people out individually. However, if you have no idea where money is going, then paying a bit more attention is worthwhile
I agree with Physician on Fire though I do see some benefit in this approach. While my wife and I don’t make Biglaw or Doctor Money, we’re doing okay and are both frugal. However, I do think that it might be beneficial to have a spending plan/budget, or whatever you want to call it to track our expenses and to see where it all goes. The recording of it seems like it can be time-consuming, especially if you use cash/check sometimes. Also, for those travel hacking, it would seem like there might be some confusion if you make big purchases of gift cards or something of that nature. Re-allocating money or moving money around in the budget also seems like it would take up some time when ultimately you can afford the expense and are saving a good amount.
In any case, I do feel that a method to track our expenses would be helpful but I’m still not sure I’d have the patience to go this route.
Budgeting sounds extreme, but if I could convey one point it would be that I do not spend any more time messing with my finances than I did pre-YNAB. There was an upfront cost to get into the system and understand how it works but now I spend the same (or less) amount of time maintaining everything.
I love that I just read your budgets are for beginners post and this one, which are contradictory, but I still completely agreed with both.
For me personally, I use YNAB as well and feel that if anything it saves me time of having to login to all my accounts separately to check my spending (and monitor everything). I have the personality for budgeting, and I do feel like it gives me that 1% edge over where I’d be if I didn’t keep up on my finances consistently.
On the other hand, I think an automatic savings plan where you save first and then spend the rest is a completely legitimate, great method as well. I just don’t think it saves as much time as one might think when you have to constantly monitor your account and still ideally track your expenses (even if only in total) to make sure you aren’t going in the negative.
So, yes, I’m on team Budgeting is for Professionals :).
YNAB enthusiast here. The Millionaire Next Door says “On average, millionaires spend significantly more hours per month studying and planning their future investment decisions, as well as managing their current investments, than high-income nonmillionaires.” YNAB works for me and I can’t imagine life without it.
I did not know about YNAB. I’m using a self made budgetting system in excel (all with pivot tables, vlookups, etc…) but I I go one week without entering my info it is a drag to do. This could be a tool that i can update on the fly as my expenses occur. I’m reviewing options, to automate part of this process. Thanks for the tip!
YNAB is a bit of a strange name but it’s definitely worth giving a shot. It started out as a spreadsheet and grew from there so it still has the feeling of a well-made spreadsheet.
I’ve heard great things about YNAB. I don’t budget monthly any longer, but I used to be pretty detailed a decade ago. I think that initial practice really helped to set my frame of mind to buy things with intent and reconsider the “optional” purchases. I will forecast once per year just to make sure I know the major cash flow requirements to come… especially now that my kids are making a dent in the food expenses! 😉
I’m glad you agree that this book is really amazing. Great article too. I’m more in the “budgets are too granular” camp myself, but you’re right that tracking it can definitely give you an edge.